Modern China : Late Qing Dynasty’s Fiscal State

Interesting titbits

  • Before mid 19th century, govt revenue was slow after Kangxi froze tax. Tax was on agriculture product. Jiangnan, Jiangsu and Zhejiang accounted for 75% of the tax revenue (grain). 
  • The grains are distributed through rivers to the granaries in the capital, then to the military garrison and finally to court. Redistributions happened from the wealthier provinces to even out the poorer provinces.
  • Massive growth in taxes occured as a result of the Taiping Rebellion. Qing govt moved from taxing agriculture to commercial levies like customs and transits from the transporting of goods. (It started because the key revenue producing provinces experienced losses being close to the front lines.)
  • Unequal treaties increased customs receipts when greater volume of trades eg cotton and opium increased provided money for greater defense spending. Shanghai provided 1/3 of tax receipts.  
  • Revenue from customs shot up  rapidly after Shimonoseki and Boxer indemnities – is China had to find money to pay for them.
  • Money has to be found to support the suppression of Muslim rebellions in Gansu, Xinjiang, Qinghai and Yunnan. Revenues now supported mostly defense spending instead of aiding poorer provinces. Greater defeats in military translated to even lesser aid to poorer provinces.
  • Most interesting:  Decline of Qing dynasty is as a narrative is doubtful since there is a lot of creativity amongst provincial officials to change the Fiscal policy to generate tax funds. 

I’m reading : “Money, Power, and the State: The Originals of the Military Fiscal State in Modern China”  written by Stephen R. Haley in Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient 56 (2013) pp 392-432

The last of the blogs

Surprised to find Transparent-hummingbird has gone dark. I hope she has found someone reliable and gone and got married! I remember her and her friends more than I remember the names of my secondary school classmates not on my facebook. Ha!

Seriously, I need a list of Singaporean bloggers – not the ones with a “theme”. Just your everyday journalist.       

The Making Of a Fiscal State in Song China, 960 – 1279.

William Guanglin Liu

The Economic History Review Vol 68 No. 1 (Feb 2015)

I have never read about Chinese economic history assuming the lack of data. I was surprised & convinced by the arguments put forward in this article. It had a clear step by step explanation of song dynasty move into a fiscal state.

1. Song dynasty moved a significant & large portion of fax revenue from direct taxes on land to indirect taxes (ie excise). Indirect taxes were collected from tea, salt & alcohol trades.

2. The state developed tax professional and processes to deal with tax collection across the land.

3.The state began to use promissory notes.

The thing I have been wondering is, why China, who had rather obvious developements in the past sort of forgot all these advancements. What if technological advancements were not born out of need but of intellectual curiosity? Need may not be a practical need – it could be for the desire to brag as well. If there was no need for the country to brag, to compete, to fight, to show off in general, the desire to innovate won’t be much supported.

So bragging has its benefits for a nation.